Any of you remember that scene in The Sopranos when they're all at Uncle Junior's party to celebrate his hung jury, and he stands up to sing Core 'Ngrato ("Ungrateful Heart") and all the old Moustache Petes start to cry?
I almost hate to admit it, but that's me. Maybe it's because I've been a musician for more years than I count (not a good one, mind, but I've certainly put the time in), but music does indeed move me more than most. And a song of subtlety, of great beauty, of message, can easily move me to tears, and stay with me for a long, long time.
I'm going to cite three examples here, and the odd thing is that two of them are re-workings of other people's work. I say it's odd because I have a decided prejudice against people who make their lives as performers of other people's art. Singing another's song doesn't necessarily make you an artist, unless you really step up to the plate with a re-imagining or just blow me away with talent and subtlety. But - there it is, two out of three, who knew?
Anyway, as I tell you which songs they are, I'm going to ask that you give them a listen, especially if you've never heard them before. I can't expect a similar emotional response, or even any emotional response whatsoever, but at very least you'll know what triggers one in me.
The three songs, in no particular order, are these:
First up is Eva Cassidy's Fields of Gold. This is a complete rework of a limpwristed throwaway tune by Sting. Cassidy, her life tragically cut down by cancer before she became famous, imparted the song with the emotional weight it deserves - the lyrics describing a couple growing old and looking back on their lives - and gives the song a feel that is 180 degrees different from Sting's. Stories abound all over the Internet of people bursting into tears the first time they've heard it: in fact I played it once for a coworker in my office, and when I looked up from some busywork I was doing I saw she was weeping. Not just tears, but actually weeping, at the power of her performance.
The second song is Jeff Buckley's version of Leonard Cohen's Hallelujah. This one gets me just from the sheer beauty of the song. It holds no particular deep message but it's just goddamned brilliant. A perfect execution of a song pretty damned good to begin with. Of the three songs here, this is the one that you'l likely know.
Finally the last song on the list, yet not nearly last in any other way, is the Pogues' Fairytale of New York. I'm not sure any words I have are fit here, so I'll just clam up and ask that you give it a listen:
So - there you go. I'll admit it: I'm a pussy when it comes to music that stirs me. Tough shit. Don't like it? Stop reading me. Wanna fight about it? Well, I don't, didn't I just say that I was a pussy?
Hope you like these songs. Let me know what you think of them.
Never watched the Soprano's - thanks for asking.
ReplyDeleteWell you ought to.
ReplyDeleteI knew Buckley had an amazing voice, but I'd never heard of Cassiday. She's amazing, too.
ReplyDeleteYeah. It kills me that there's that kind of talent in the world and that I'll never even come close.
ReplyDeleteEva Cassidy...wow. She is amazing. Sorry, but I didn't care for the Pogues. I've never liked performers whose lyrics are barely discernible or who regularly sing out of tune. It's one of the many reasons I think the Rolling Stones may be the most overrated band in history.
ReplyDeleteI'm completely with you though on the whole crying over music thing. I'm a big sap when it comes to movies and TV shows too, but nothing does it to me like music. Heck, I cry over songs that aren't even meant to be sad or especially emotional all the time.
Lending credence, I think, to the notion that it's a musician thing...
DeleteI cry at the diamond commercials.
DeleteI need to get headphone for work so I can listen to your pussy songs.
ReplyDeleteHardly matters - probably wouldn't have any impact on the emotionally dead such as yourself.
DeleteWaffles isn't emotionally dead, he's just stunted.
DeleteEmotions are lame.
ReplyDeleteI became a musician
to get myself laid.
It's human nature
ReplyDeleteTo ask you, walking loser,
How far'd that get you?
I'm wondering now;
DeleteWas "walking loser" maybe
A tiny bit harsh?
Have to say, now, that--
ReplyDeletewith 20/20 hindsight--
No. It did not work.
My thought on that is:
ReplyDeletethat you should get run over
by a lawnmow'r blade.
I chose to end in song.